Think They’re Too Old to Hire? The Data Says Otherwise.

"She looks overqualified." "He's probably close to retirement."

"Why would someone with that much experience even apply for this job?"

As an executive recruiter with more than 30 years in the industry, I've heard these comments more times than I can count. And lately, I've found myself asking employers a simple question:

What if we put assumptions aside and just had a conversation?


The Resume That Sparked a Conversation

Recently, I was speaking with the owner of a company in Iowa that needed to replace a retiring Controller. During our conversation, he mentioned that he had received a resume from a local applicant who, based on the dates and experience listed, appeared to be at least 65 years old.

His question was direct: "Why would she apply?"

My response was equally simple: "Maybe she's not done working."

I shared a story about my dad. When he turned 65, he approached his employer and made a deal. He promised to continue giving his full commitment and dedication to the organization if they would keep him on as long as he was able and willing to contribute.

I'm proud to say they honored that agreement and my dad worked until he was 70.

The Data May Surprise You

We often assume that hiring an older worker means hiring someone who is heading out the door. Yet labor market data tells a very different story.

According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, the median tenure for all U.S. workers is just 3.9 years.

But look at how tenure increases with age:

  • Ages 16-19: 0.7 years

  • Ages 20-24: 1.4 years

  • Ages 25-34: 2.7 years

  • Ages 35-44: 4.6 years

  • Ages 45-54: 7.0 years

  • Ages 55-64: 9.6 years

  • Ages 65+: 9.8 years

Think about that for a moment. The age group that many employers worry may retire soon actually has the highest median tenure of any age group in the workforce.

Why Might Older Workers Stay Longer?

Nobody can know an individual's future plans without asking them. But there are several possible reasons older employees often demonstrate longer tenure:

They value opportunity.

Many experienced professionals have encountered age-related assumptions during the hiring process. When an employer takes the time to genuinely evaluate them based on skills and capability, that opportunity may create a deeper sense of loyalty and commitment.

They know who they are.

As we progress through our careers, many of us become more settled in what we enjoy doing and where we add the most value. The desire to constantly chase the next title or climb the next rung of the ladder often diminishes.

Retirement looks different today.

People are living longer, staying healthier, and remaining professionally engaged well beyond traditional retirement age. Some continue working because they enjoy it. Others want to stay connected, challenged, and productive.

The idea that everyone wants to stop working at 65 simply isn't reality for many professionals.

Let's Talk About the Other Assumptions

I've also heard concerns that older applicants:

  • Won't adapt to new technology.

  • Aren't as agile as younger workers.

  • Will demand excessive compensation.

  • Will be resistant to change.

Maybe. But maybe not. The problem is that these are assumptions.

I've met 30-year-olds who struggle with change and 68-year-olds who eagerly embrace AI, new systems, and continuous learning.

I've met younger candidates whose compensation expectations were far above market and seasoned professionals willing to trade title and salary for meaningful work, flexibility, and stability.

A resume can tell you where someone has been.

A conversation tells you where they want to go next.

The Outcome

A few weeks after my conversation with the Iowa business owner, I followed up to see how the search was progressing.

He shared that he had hired a local candidate who was 65 years old. More importantly, she told him she had no plans to retire anytime soon.

Did that conversation alone change his perspective? I can't say for certain.

What I do know is that someone who might have been overlooked received an opportunity. A company gained an experienced Controller and an individual who still wanted to contribute found a place where she could.

While there was no recruiting fee generated from that conversation, I'd like to think something valuable happened.

If we helped change one life and one career by encouraging someone to have a conversation instead of making an assumption, that's a win worth celebrating!

Before You Pass, Pick Up the Phone

The next time a resume lands on your desk from someone who appears "overqualified" or "too close to retirement," pause before making a decision.

Ask yourself:

  • What if they're looking for stability?

  • What if they want to contribute rather than climb?

  • What if their experience could help mentor your next generation of leaders?

  • What if they're exactly the employee who will stay the longest?

You won't find those answers on a resume. You'll find them in a conversation.

Let's Talk

At CFO Systems Recruiting, we're passionate about helping employers look beyond assumptions and identify exceptional talent at every career stage.

If your organization is struggling to find accounting, finance, HR, operations, or leadership talent, let's have a conversation. You might be surprised by the opportunities hiding in plain sight.

Contact us to discuss your hiring needs or explore talent strategies that expand your candidate pool and improve hiring outcomes.

CFO Systems — We Help Our Clients Grow!


Originally published on LinkedIn by Patty North. View the original post.


CFO Systems was founded in 2004 in Omaha, Nebraska, and serves clients across America with Fractional, Interim, and Recruiting professionals. CFO Systems includes a team with over 3,500 years of experience as CFOs, COOs, Controllers, HR Executives, IT Project Managers, FP&A Professionals, Supply Chain Experts, and accounting staff. The firm has been named on the Inc. 5000 list of fastest growing companies 10 times in the last 12 years. Headquartered in Omaha, Nebraska, CFO Systems serves clients nationwide while working either on-site or remotely. Visit www.cfosystemsllc.com for more information.

SOURCE: CFO Systems

Next
Next

Are Hiring Delays Really a Candidate Problem?